The Combine Forum banner
1 - 12 of 12 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
2,970 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 · (Edited)
I have had the cylinder removed for about a month on our 740. Ordered a sunnybrook but before installing it, wanted to change a few things. My main focus was the impeller. Even with the wear kit and flow kit, I still get build-up of material on the back and top side of impeller in the mid section. This material wears on the impeller and definitely hurts flow and efficiency. To me, it is obvious that the build up, only occuring in soybeans, is because the stem going through the machine sideways, gets wrapped around the rotor nose and can't decide which rotor to go into. These long, stringy stems that are cross-ways just hang on the nose, and do nothing but cause other stems to hang up. So to take care of this, I cut a groove in the impeller about an inch deep and 1/2" wide. On the nose of the rotors, I welded two corn head cutting stalk roll knives together. In doing so, when the impeller is feeding the rotors, material in the middle will be cut in half, one side going to one rotor and the other side to the other. I feel confident in this modification working but time will tell.



Another area I tweaked with the cylinder out was the "ceiling" of the machine above the APS and cylinder. My machine runs pretty quiet while running empty, but once I enter the crop and the material starts to be threshed, the grain noise becomes very noticable. Based on the "ceiling" being shiny from material, I am assuming what I am hearing is from grain and material being slung around and hitting this sheet metal. What I did was cut out cardboard with many holes in it and hold it up to the ceiling. The ceiling has two supports underneath about an inch lower than the sheet metal. I took expandable foam and filled this 1" void between the cardboard and upper sheet metal. It will be an interesting trial and maybe short-lived, as card board and foam isn't the most durable material. What I liked about it is it wont have voids that can fill up with material such as stems and dust, and if it falls down, it won't cause harm to the combine.

The next area I changed was a gap between the back of the pre-concave and the front of the round bar concave. The front of the rb actually has a keystock on the leading edge. That is fine, but there is no holes in front of it for grain to fall through. This looks like a prime area for seed damage, especially in soybeans. I pop riveted 2"x3/16x 56" flat metal IIRC. It made the floor smooth for better seed protection.

The last item I changed here was the back of the concave where the bent bar bolts on to the top, just below the impeller. It had a void where crop definitely speared into instead of a smooth flow. I found this void to be useless again, as there were no holes for grain to go out of. I just filled this area up with bondo. It may not last very long, but I feel this round bar concave may not be used much longer as it isn't very "round" anymore from soybeans. The mid section is looking pretty flat.

To wrap all of this up, I did one other change to the rotor grates. I feel the smooth round grates aren't aggressive enough to get the crop to tumble and release the grain. Part of my theory is based off of the axial flow design and its effectiveness of using a small area. I bought some "t" bolts from Mcmaster Carr that fit the exact spacing of the grates. I welded some 5/16x6" keystock to it so it sits down on the grate from the inside. All of this is secured to the grate with a serrated 1/2" bolt. All of it can be installed from below the rotors laying on the shaker pan. ( I relocated the sieve light back to another hole. By doing so, dropping the shaker pan only requires removing 6, 13mm bolts and 1 minute.) I installed five of these in staggered pattern on each rotor. Disregard the torch grooves that are shown on the pictured keystock. I forgot to grind some weld down and only had a torch for that one.

BTW, the sunnybrook runs smoother than ever (in the shed anyway). When tightening the bearings for the cylinder, make sure the cylinder spins freely while tightening the bearing taper. If the cylinder turns hard when tightened, redo and hold the cylinder to one side of the machine or the other with a pry bar. It seems possible if you don't do this, the pre-load on the side of the bearings could cause pre-mature damage.


Critique away guys!
 

Attachments

· Premium Member
Joined
·
6,300 Posts
Seedcleaner thank you for posting the pictures. It will be very interesting to see how the impeller and dogs tongue modification at the entrance of the rotors works. To bad harvest you won't be harvesting tomorrow to let us know how it works. I will also be interested if the disrupters in the rotor helps with the rotor grain loss and whether it increases your power requirement. How did you space them out or are they evenly space along the bottom of the rotor?
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
6,300 Posts
Seedcleaner while you have it apart I would weld in some "v's" into the back of the concave. This is one thing I would have done if I had to do it again. I would also check your rotor bearings if you haven't before you put everything together. One of mine was shot so I replaced both of them. It is much easier to do while it is apart. For your impeller did you just static balance it?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,970 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·
Seedcleaner thank you for posting the pictures. It will be very interesting to see how the impeller and dogs tongue modification at the entrance of the rotors works. To bad harvest you won't be harvesting tomorrow to let us know how it works. I will also be interested if the disrupters in the rotor helps with the rotor grain loss and whether it increases your power requirement. How did you space them out or are they evenly space along the bottom of the rotor?
I am looking forward to hopefully no more build-up at the rotors!

Last fall for soybean harvest, I installed ten T bolts in the grates, without keystock. The idea was good but I don't think there was enough edge to do much disruption. Now, 6 inches will make a difference. They are staggered on the grates. The front one is just behind the factory cover plates, and the back one is on the last grate I think. Most of them are installed closer to the wall of the machine, instead of the middle. If anything, the machine naturally loads heavier in the middle I think, based on more cylinder and concave wear in the middle.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,970 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
Seedcleaner while you have it apart I would weld in some "v's" into the back of the concave. This is one thing I would have done if I had to do it again. I would also check your rotor bearings if you haven't before you put everything together. One of mine was shot so I replaced both of them. It is much easier to do while it is apart. For your impeller did you just static balance it?
You can see one V I bolted in a year ago on the concave. I am hesitant to weld on these electronic machines anymore!

I put new rotor bearing in when I did the flow kit. One was bad because my thick grease leaked more at the fitting, than what went in the bearing. Lock n Lube solved that, and nlgi #1 grease.

I feel the impeller balance isn't very critical, as it is a small diameter. It also doesn't have areas to trap dust like the factory cylinder. I figure if the factory cylinder can work off balance, the impeller will be fine. Everything seemed to run very smooth at 1200 rpm in the shed!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,584 Posts
Lexion engineering!

Seedcleaner while you have it apart I would weld in some "v's" into the back of the concave. This is one thing I would have done if I had to do it again. I would also check your rotor bearings if you haven't before you put everything together. One of mine was shot so I replaced both of them. It is much easier to do while it is apart. For your impeller did you just static balance it?
Interesting ideas Seedcleaner! I think it is great that you take the time to try some of the good ideas that you also came up with. I personally think that some of these mods that we do are each a small step in the right direction to making a combine work better, for our unique harvesting conditions and crops. Good for you and thanks for sharing pics.

I really like your cutter on the impeller. I feel that the 500's and 700's lack the ability to split the flow into the rotors. In some crops, specially long green wirey straw, it creates a bottleneck in this area and that is causing some of the plugging and feeding problems that seem to be quite common. The cutter that you have created might just end that hangup point. The V shaped splitter you have on the back of your concave is a step in the right direction. Do you remember the vanes on my 480 corn concaves? They seem to split the flow very well. What you are doing is starting with a different design but working toward the same end result. Looks good!:)

Will your keystock interrupters stay put or would 2 mounting bolts be better? Seems like they should help with separation.

You will have your cab so quiet that you will have design a heads up tach display onto the windshield to know if you are still running!!;)

Are you saying that thinner grease is better for the rotor bearings? I can not see why the original trunnions would not work with regard to grease flow but yet they were a problem. My tech is saying that poor grease flow is still a problem after the upgrade, but simply more grease is a partial answer to the problem. I have been greasing mine 10 shots a day each but he is thinking that 20 or 30 a day may be good insurance to insure that grease is actually getting to the bearings. What do you guys think?

What do you guys think about the Sunnybrook cylinder? SouthernSK , you have run one a year now. Do the crow's feet help? What about feeding crop and splitting the flow to the impeller??? Interesting thread:)
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,970 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
Thanks transaxial. I think the v concave design works in dry material but I just don't see it being effective enough on stems that have moisture that are crossways in the middle of the machine. I simply believe any material going crossways in the middle needs cut in half so it can continue its transition into the rotors.

I started with the t bolts thinking they would do what I wanted without keystock. After viewing how minute they appeared in relation to the seperating area, I wanted more...I'm only human! Because I already had the t bolts and they can be installed without disassembly, I used them. Starting over, a nut welded on the backside of the keystock on each end would be just fine...stronger, but would have to have correct spacing so the bolts don't interfere with the wire grates.

Looking forward to the s.b. sure ran smooth.

Anybody have pics of updated tailing conveyor outlet? I am going to mod mine instead of buying kit.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,970 Posts
Discussion Starter · #9 ·
How many acres have you put on that concave? What crops did you run through it? I'm just curious how long a concave should last.

Thats a good question. I will look closer at the monitor sometime but I think the "effective working hours" are around 700. Probably closer to 600 on that concave. It came with a keystock concave that I used some when the machine was new. I think the roundbar is a very durable concave from bending, but I too am surprised how it has worn already. On the other hand, this machine does a lot of soybeans and I have been in some really dusty conditions. That really wears on the components quicker than corn or wheat, especially on a per bushel basis.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,584 Posts
I think the v concave design works in dry material but I just don't see it being effective enough on stems that have moisture that are crossways in the middle of the machine. I simply believe any material going crossways in the middle needs cut in half so it can continue its transition into the rotors.
Quote from Seedcleaner

Yes I agree, and your "cutter" looks like it will be very aggressive at splitting the flow of those tough, green, long stems that are causing the problem buildup. Do you have your patent registered before you posted pictures? LOL

How much grease is enough in those front rotor trunnions to keep the bearings lubricated?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
71 Posts
seedcleaner....
It will be interesting to see how well your "rotor disruptors" work this coming year. I think that you are onto something there, as rotor loss in certain conditions and certain corn hybrids has been an issue for us too. Keep us posted.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,970 Posts
Discussion Starter · #12 ·
Getafterit, rotor loss happens at times. In my mind, the area of separation is very large. Many say if you have rotor loss, especially in corn, that you aren't properly threshing at the front of the machine. I agree for the most part, but again, when you compare what a typical axial flow has for its smaller space...large keystock...it does pretty good. When conditions get tough, the single rotors lose more, but generally, I think the lexion grates need to be more aggressive.

I could actually see a benefit of pulling two mid-grates on the lexion, four total, and making them keystock. It would hurt straw quality if you do that. Could also overload sieves in dry conditions. If it does that, you are probably not having rotor loss and could slow rotor speed to minimize the negatives.
 
1 - 12 of 12 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top