The Combine Forum banner

Stay Green or go Red?

5.5K views 28 replies 14 participants last post by  youngharvester  
#1 ·
Currently have a 9610 and am pleased with it. Will be buying another combine for this summers wheat harvest and would like a rotary. The problem is I cant afford a 9660 which would be my choice of Deere's. I am considering a C-IH 2388. Will I regret getting away from Deere? Will cut wheat only with average yields around 40 bu/acre.
 
#6 ·
To answer your question better in 40 bushel wheat with a 30-36foot header I'd say you will be runnin 5.5-7mph all day long. I'd go for an afx or a st rotor above anything else. 2388 is neck and neck with 9660-9760 and they are a lot more affordable. Probably the most common combine among custom harvesters. the machine itself isn't ridiculously large but it has large capacity make sure it has bin ext's. And get the monitor too. If it's programmed right it will be within 3/4 of a point on moisture. If not closer. A 9610 and a 2388 are too way different machines. It is a lot bigger job to change concaves and grates on the green one. The 88 has a lot bigger cleaning system. And the grain quality is hard to compare with. I could go on and on pm me for more.
 
#9 ·
There are bugs with every machine out there. I've seen a brand new 9660 start blowing up hydraulic components and by the time it got fixed it was damaged goods for the rest of its existence. Those horror stories aren't brand specific however CNH machines are hard to beat when they are performing properly.
 
#10 ·
I would recommend the specialty rotor with gordon rotor bars on the front, kile mfg rotor kit for the afx style, and cover plates on the front half of concaves if needed. I am looking forward to trying the gordon wheat sieves, as I was happy with the soybean sieves from him. Good luck. These are the add-ons I have and am very happy, but even a factory 2388 will do a good job.
 
#12 ·
Farmer Tony I can make that statement from personal experience and documented breakdowns on 2 8010's a 2003 and 2005 model. But Iam sure that CNH has all the bugs worked out of the new ones thats what they told me to get me to trade to the 2005 instead of giving me our money back. but it was worse if anything. I guess it did quit catching on fire everyday. The spreader is the same junk. electronics are the same, control pressure failure?? you can go on and on there was always something.
 
#15 ·
We could all argue all day long about how much better green is than red or the other way around. I prefer deeres over the 2388's based on the length of the feeder house. 2388's are very dependable and not that hard to work on, but if your used to a deere that short feederhouse will cause a few fatigued days for you until a person get used to it. just my 2 cents
 
#17 ·
9010 I see your from Grand Island I went on the tour when my 1'st 8010 came off the line. I also had the prototype run when they were developing 8010. Grand Island is why I thought you might build them. We had an engineer here from GI when it was on fire it happened at least once a day. they did redesign airflow and the 05 never did it. but his question was about 2388. They are a great machine and most dealerships can fix them. we had 3 of them. They don't have as much capacity as 9660 in dry corn but we never ran against 9660 in wheat so i would not know. 2388's are cheaper than deere also. proabably a good choice.
 
#19 ·
Why I am changing from green to red
First is handling green stem beans and tough wheat straw. We double crop about all our beans so we are always trying to cut wheat about 3 days before it is ready so bunching is a real problem same with green stem beans so we are changing to draper to try to get a better feed.
I also wanted to try a Red machine I liked what I saw when I rode in one.
And last we have the worlds worst Green dealer in this area.
I don't think Green equipment is junk they make good stuff I just thought they were second place in what I needed.
 
#20 ·
jdm going to an sts would also given you a huge improvement in your green stem beans. Seems like everyon new the STS would be an improvement in corn over the conventional, but for me there was a bigger improvement in the handleing the green stem beans that we have all come to love. IMO the sts is maybe better than the AFX rotor for beans but the small tube i think will tilt it back to red. No matter what colot the draper will make it better.
 
#21 ·
I've seen an 88 like warrens humming along at 3-3.5 in a 120+++ wheat crop and a 9660 at 1 mph in a 100 bushel wheat crop that was constantly one milisecond from slugging it guts. the funny thing was the 88 was an 03 (first year of the afx) and 9660 was an 06 (several years into production). IMHO it was no contest the 88 would have ran in circles around the 9660 in a heavy yielding irrigated wheat crop.
 
#23 ·
They were both taking in a lot of straw I'll tell you the big difference there was an operaider running the 88 and a poser running the 60. the 60 was an 05 and it was all of about two months before the bullet rotor was released cuz harvesters were complaining that the sts couldn't hack it in irrigated wheat with big yields. The 60 was running not too far from your neck of the woods near ducor CA.
 
#25 ·
This may seem a little off topic, but I spent some time harvesting with my uncle in 1999(iirc). At the time, the 9610 was pretty new. We were running a 1680, and the farmer we were cutting for had a new 9610. In 50-60 bpa dryland winter wheat, the 1680 was able to keep the same pace as the 9610 while sending less out the back. If a 1680 can do that, I think a 2388 would be able to do even better.

Another note: in my experience (which is admittedly limited; I'm only 22), I find the rotaty machines much more pleasant to run because of the way they suck in the dust around the feederhouse. Especially at night. Makes it easier to see what's going on. Just my $0.02.
 
#26 ·
Quote:Another note: in my experience (which is admittedly limited; I'm only 22), I find the rotaty machines much more pleasant to run because of the way they suck in the dust around the feederhouse. Especially at night. Makes it easier to see what's going on. Just my $0.02.
I think that is something you get with the AFX rotor. Using specialty rotors, which just have the elephant ears on the front of the rotor, allows some air to go out the feederhouse.

-Lance