The Combine Forum banner
21 - 34 of 34 Posts
I was looking at some of those. They do seem to have a pretty good reputation. The issue I had was its about $1,000 for the mechanical portion of the conversion and another $3,000 to convert the electronics. I'm not sure if its worth it or not.
It's worth it and if you raise some garbs it won't take long to pay for that head. Augers are hard to beet messing with fluffy crop and they flex as good as anything. They are popular for good reason.
 
Discussion starter · #22 ·
It's worth it and if you raise some garbs it won't take long to pay for that head. Augers are hard to beet messing with fluffy crop and they flex as good as anything. They are popular for good reason.
Your reasoning here is what lead me towards looking at something like a Case 3020 header in the first place. Drapers are just too much money right now and from what I understand a full fingered auger header works just as well, if not better, in canola. I guess the big question is when looking at headers in the $20k-$25k range, are the JD ones $4,000 better than the Case ones?
 
I would go with an auger flex. I think it's the best bang for you buck and the most versatile. We have a 630R, 630D, 630F and a 635F. We have demoed 635FD's and 640Fd's and were really impressed with them but they are just to high in price for our operation when there is other alternatives. Since we are growing more soybeans and straight cutting canola more now the auger flex fits the bill pretty well and they are cheap compared to a draper. I actually think they do a better job straight cutting canola then a draper and I have used both before. More places for canola seeds to run onto the ground with a draper. Then you also need a cross auger for sure to on the draper. I have also had problems with the drive rollers gumming up and canvasses slipping from crushed canola seed. This year we used our 3 auger headers to cut the canola with and it was the best experience we have ever had straight cutting canola compared to when we tried with our drapers in past years. Now our 630D is kind of the black sheep in the yard as the only thing it's good for is cutting wheat and hopefully our acres will be dwindling in that respect.
 
Your reasoning here is what lead me towards looking at something like a Case 3020 header in the first place. Drapers are just too much money right now and from what I understand a full fingered auger header works just as well, if not better, in canola. I guess the big question is when looking at headers in the $20k-$25k range, are the JD ones $4,000 better than the Case ones?
Have not used a 3020 but have used a 2020 and own a 1020. Of them two headers a 900 series Deere is hands down better so yeah, if I was in your shoes I wouldn't bat and eye at even 10k more. And for comparison I do own a 930F
 
Your reasoning here is what lead me towards looking at something like a Case 3020 header in the first place. Drapers are just too much money right now and from what I understand a full fingered auger header works just as well, if not better, in canola. I guess the big question is when looking at headers in the $20k-$25k range, are the JD ones $4,000 better than the Case ones?
From what I have seen cutting soybeans, I think they are. Mainly for the reason that you can set your float pressure from the cab and go into full rigid also. For us that is nice because we cut wheat, canola and beans with ours.
 
So if your farm was split wheat/canola would you keep the draper or do it all with the 630f?
If we were a 50/50 split I would have both then. The auger head isn't quite as nice as the draper in wheat but since our wheat acres are going down I would get by with just the auger flex now. We run two combines and landed up with 4 headers. Even if you added up the value of all 4 of them, we wouldn't be able to buy a new flex draper. Atleast this way if one header craps out during the day we can just pull another one out and don't have a huge investment in one single header to rely on for everything. Finished off the year with a broken knife in the draper and on one flex header.
 
I wouldn't.
The floating header on a MacDon adapter just make easier and safer running on rolling ground at high speed and after a few simple modifications the only limitation is engine power limit in any crop even on a 780.
Ahhh but Don we are running just those small JD combines that never go over two mph so that isn't an issue for us.
 
Ahhh but Don we are running just those small JD combines that never go over two mph so that isn't an issue for us.
Ah ha, lol.
I'm just no fan of headers utilizing ground contact sensors to electric/hydraulically control a rigidly attached header.
The entire header of a MacDon is ground sensing and the float springs take care of instant ground changes, much smoother.
I hope MacDon never goes away from float springs.
Um, actually...:54::)
 
Has anyone used a vari feed new holland headder on a case combine? And are the vari feed the answer for all crops?

I'm looking at trying the vari feed this spring to pick up standing canola as soon as the snow melts.
 
21 - 34 of 34 Posts